How to Reapply After a Rejection

She was a senior human-resources professional who was laid off in summer 2009 from her job at large hospital in Texas. After the layoff, she did everything she knew from her years in HR would help her land a job. She woke early every day, put on her business suit, networked like mad, lunched with contacts ... the whole nine yards.

Still, no job offers came; just those cold-as-silicon, automatically generated rejection letters. You know the kind: vaguely worded, anonymously sent e-mails saying they've received your application and will contact you if they see a fit.

Yeah, right. Don't hold your breath.

The HR pro didn't. Instead, she contacted Laurie M. Winslow, principal at Talent Innovations Group. Winslow looked at her resume, saw that it did a good job making the case that she was management material, reformatted the document and used the HR pro's list of connections until she found one who knew a senior management member of one of the companies to which she had already applied. She then told the HR pro to resubmit the new resume to all those automatic online application sites.

The job seeker did reapply, changing her e-mail address so it wouldn't appear to be a duplicate. She was hired for one of the positions for which she was originally rejected.

Was it the contact that did the trick, or was it the reformatted, resubmitted resume? Probably both, but what really matters is that she bounced back, tweaked her resume and reapplied.

It's not you, it's your resume

We contacted HR professionals who work with resume applicant tracking systems (ATS), and all of them said the same thing: If you've received a computer-generated rejection letter for a position for which you believe you are qualified, you should understand that your resume has been rejected, not you.

In such cases, the issue may be that your resume lacks specific keywords and search terms or the format caused a problem for the software. In that case, Winslow said, a smart applicant “will immediately contact the recruitment office of the rejecting organization. If they cannot get through to the appropriate recruiter, I would advise that they speak with a sympathetic administrative assistant —anyone who can guide them as to the best way for them to replace the resume currently in the ATS with one containing the correct keywords and phrases. And once their customized resume has been submitted, I would encourage them to contact the appropriate recruiter (or sympathetic administrative assistant) and request that their updated resume be reviewed for the open position.”

Read on for more tips about how to tweak a resume and reapply after receiving an automated rejection letter.

Best practices for jumping back into the ATS

Winslow advises her clients to change the e-mail address they use to submit their applications, since e-mail is the primary identifier used by common ATS software to sort resumes, and changing it will probably convince the ATS it's a new application. (More-advanced ATS programs, like Taleo, use multiple candidate identifiers, Winslow said, but multiple applications are still OK, so long as the content remains accurate.)

And it doesn't hurt to reach a human on the other side of the ATS. Winslow recommended applicants use LinkedIn or other networking tools to find a contact within the company to whom they can speak about why you think you're a good fit for the position.

“Don't be afraid to pick up the phone and call,” Winslow said. “Use LinkedIn or whatever networking tool you have to reach out and say, ‛Hey, have you really looked at this application?' ”

Tell them that you've reworked your original resume to show more accurately why you're the best candidate for the position and that you'd like to reapply, but make sure you don't put anyone on the defensive by insinuating that they made a mistake.

Where to restrain your tweaking

When looking at a resume, recruiters look to make sure that, if there are multiples, no significant data has been altered. To avoid appearing flaky at best and fraudulent at worst, keep the work history consistent, and don't change company names for which you've worked, titles you've held, education, or months and years at the companies. Bottom line: Executive summaries and bulleted lists of key skills and achievements are the areas to tweak, not work-history sections.

“As long as those things [in the work-history section] stay the same,” Winslow said, “if you just change the resume format to something more usable and more applicable to the job description, there's nothing wrong with that, as long as you don't falsify information.”

Tiffani Murray is the manager of technology and metrics for the talent-acquisition department of a major beverage manufacturer. Murray's position includes managing the ATS for her large company, which uses the Peopleclick software application. Murray's advice for applicants who initially get rejected and who want to modify their resumes is to pay attention not only to the resume — make sure the keywords replicate the job posting, for example — but how the data is collected in the system. For example, some company career sites merely allow you to upload your resume, while others require users to fill in specific fields, such as job title or skills.

In their rush to complete the online application, many applicants might skip over these and other fields with multiple selection boxes, she said. On the second attempt, Murray stresses the importance of applicants taking the time to fill in all of the information requested, even if it's listed as optional. “I recommend this because in many of the systems, these fields of information become searchable for the recruiters on the other side,” she said. Fill it all in, even if information such as years of experience or degrees is listed on your resume. It's impossible to know when a recruiter might sort by this information to filter out applicants, and filling in all fields will ensure you don't erroneously get caught in a screening filter.

Lisa Vaas covers resume writing techniques and the technology behind the job search for TheLadders.





Featured Jobs

CEO/Head of School

Creative Learning Academy of Pensacola, Inc. “CLA” is seeking a chief executive to become Head of School beginning with the 2013-2014 school year. The successful candidate must have a history of significant business leadership and a proven track record of growth. Experience at an accredited independent school preferred, but not required.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Development

The WRUS Director of Development will have the opportunity to work within a collaborative, student centered professional environment, vigilant in our dedication to the success of bright high school students with learning differences, bound for college and post secondary learning.

Click to see complete job & apply

Fundraising and Development Director

Major Non-Profit organization in Carlsbad, NM is looking for a Fundraising and Development Director to join their team. This candidate must be someone with a proven track record developing and coordinating annual giving, donor stewardship and securing other forms of giving for a major Non-Profit organization.

Click to see complete job & apply

Major Gifts Officer

The International Fellowship of Christians and Jews ( The Fellowship ) is seeking a resourceful and dynamic individual as a Major Gifts Officer to promote our mission and build strong support among major donors. The MGO will engage, cultivate, and solicit current and prospective major donors in the western region of the US.

Click to see complete job & apply

Regional Director

The Regional Director supports multiple Executive Directors (EDs, 5-6) and community based Boards of Directors (5-6) in their region, serves as the Chief Executive of the region and is responsible for leadership and management development and support, board and resource development, marketing, and training needs of the assigned team members to ensure all performance goals are exceeded.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Major Gifts and Planned Giving

Responsibilities include developing and implementing a major and planned gifts development plan, and building a high-performing team, to achieve fundraising goals; managing a portfolio of donors; and serving as the primary liaison with financial advisors, attorneys, and other partners in the promotion and acquisition of gifts.

Click to see complete job & apply

Business Administrator

The position is responsible for the management of all financial and business aspects of the organization. Job responsibilities include: accounts payable and receivable, banking transactions and account, reconciliations, payroll, budget preparation and tracking, administration and record keeping of employee benefit programs, maintain all insurances, maintain donor and financial databases and preparation of financial reports.

Click to see complete job & apply

President and CEO

The United Way of Northern Arizona is seeking a proven, energetic leader as its next President and CEO. The new President and CEO will succeed the current President and CEO who is retiring after more than 14 years of outstanding, innovative leadership. UWNA has been recognized nationally for creating innovative collaborations and partnerships in its community impact areas of education, income and health.

Click to see complete job & apply


The Methodist Home for Children and Youth, a multi-faceted residential care home in Macon, Georgia, that addresses the needs of abused, neglected, and abandoned children, seeks a visionary administrator to guide and advance the operations and services as the President and CEO.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Foundation Relations

Seeking a Director of Foundation Relations to lead the effort to build and sustain relationships with national foundations and to leverage resources of the foundation community to help NSALA's reach its organizational goals and grow its new national initiative.

Click to see complete job & apply

Grants Manager

Use your experience with the grantmaking cycle to develop online applications, draft grant agreements, and track and review grantee reports. You will have primary responsibility for managing the grants management team's use of database and legal compliance technology.

Click to see complete job & apply

Chief Executive Officer

The Chief Executive Officer (CEO) oversees all operational aspects of the organization. This leader will be charged with oversight of fiscal and financial affairs, services provided, staff management, and the cultivation of community partnerships.

Click to see complete job & apply

Fundraising Manager

CRY America is CRY, Child Rights and You America Inc, a non profit organization registered in the USA in November 2002 that works towards restoring basic rights to underprivileged children, especially Indian. At CRY America we believe that each of us as individuals can make a difference.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Foundation Relations

Virginia Commonwealth University has an opening for an experienced, team-oriented Director of Foundation Relations. This position will report to the Senior Associate VP for Development and will serve as a member of the leadership team responsible for engaging national foundations. This individual will identify and cultivate new foundation partnerships on behalf of the university.

Click to see complete job & apply

Executive Director

With support and input from members of the board and staff, the Executive Director ensures the ethical integrity of the Foundation in daily operations as well as through strategic alliances and in various communiqué.

Click to see complete job & apply

Vice President of Development

Reporting directly to the President/CEO and serving on the executive team, directing a small team of fundraising professionals, this position will develop goals and strategies for fundraising programs incorporating major gifts, annual funds, government grants, corporate & foundation relations and planned giving.

Click to see complete job & apply

Senior Director, Foundation Relations

The Senior Director will focus on building high-level relationships between top foundations that will increase giving to support the American Heart Association mission. He or she will collaborate with volunteers and staff throughout the Western States Affiliate to achieve success. An emphasis will be on closing six-figure gifts to help us change and save lives.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Peer to Peer Fundraising

This position is responsible for the development and execution of the Agency's Peer to Peer fundraising strategy. The Peer to Peer strategy will focus on empowering individuals and groups to raise funds on behalf of the agency by allowing them to communicate and solicit prospective donors from their own networks and communities.

Click to see complete job & apply

More Jobs Like These »


Follow NPT

Stay Connected. Stay Informed.

Nonprofit news delivered around the clock, around the world.