What to Expect on a Second and Third Interview

Before you hear the words, “You're hired,” you will typically sit through three separate interview sessions … at least.

You prepared for the first interview. So you're prepared for the second and third interviews, right? Probably not, say human resources professionals.

Why do they even require three or more interviews? Wouldn't it be more productive for everyone to meet all the decision makers in a single session and avoid the duplicate trips and days off from your current job? Couldn't they ask you every question in a single day?

Hiring professionals structure interview schedules with specific intent and each round has a unique purpose, said several human resources managers who spoke to TheLadders. Understanding the typical schedule and purpose of each round can help you prepare for each and hand you an advantage in the hiring process.

Weeding Out

The first interview is strictly used to weed out candidates who stand out from those who simply looked good on paper (resume). Interviewers will try to ask questions to verify the claims made on a resume and the focus remains on matching the candidate to the basic job requirements — certifications, qualifications, presentation and salary.

It's a “high level chat,” said Mark Johnson, HR manager for the Americas at Serena Software in Redwood City, Calif. “This is where we are getting to know you,” Johnson said. “This is the phase where we say, ‘This is what we're looking for,' and ‘This is what we see on your resume that supports what we are looking for.'”

It's a screening process, said Gia Colosi, director of human resources, at eMeter in San Mateo, Calif., another software maker. “At this point we're looking at whether you have the technical capability to do the work.”

Layers of a Cake

The second interview is where an interviewer will begin to press for examples of specific experiences that support the candidate's claims to be the person presented in their resume.

“Think of it as layers of a cake,” said Marilyn Monarch, group director for HR consulting and services at Citrix Systems. “We're trying to find out the applicant's work history for the last five to seven years … If we're talking a second interview we've got a solid candidate. They've moved beyond being a suspect to a prospect.”

Monarch said the type of question she likes to ask in a second interview is to have the candidate speak about a recent incident where they identified an area that needed improvement in their last or current position, and then to walk her through how they went about getting it resolved.

“Sometimes you get an impactful representation of what the candidate is about,” she said. “We're listening for experience and how they present their story.”

The second interview is also a time to ensure that the candidate understands the intricacies of the position, the work involved and the compensation, Johnson noted. “I have to calibrate my expectations and their experience with what the job requires,” Monarch said.

Serena Software's Johnson says one of the most important things for him in the interview process is honesty. “For candidates it's really important to be honest,” he said. “Be very honest. Be clear about your abilities, do not overstate. We're looking for instances where the applicant has done the things they claim. But if you can't answer quickly or honestly it quickly becomes apparent in the interview process and causes it to break down.”

Do Your Research

Another key point for candidates returning for a second interview is that they know the company they are applying to.

“Be very aware of who we are as a company — what we do, what our market space is and what the team you are joining does,” Johnson said.

Robert Erzen, vice president of HR at Palo Alto Networks, a network security software provider, said, “It's critical that they know something about us. My advice is to take some time to go onto LinkedIn so they can even find a name they can drop of somebody who works here — the name of a friend of a friend even.”

Monarch says she likes to see that a candidate has done their homework on the company. “It pays to show that they are very interested in the company. They ought to know who we are, what we do and what's the scope of our business. If they stumble or don't know anything, that candidate's chances may be limited.”

Another tip from Monarch is that candidates study the company's Web site. Most corporate Web sites are robust and have lots of information. If the company in question is public, the financials as well as information about the products and services are all available online. Moreover, it also pays to know the company's competitive landscape, she said. “In the initial interview we look very simply at whether the person can make an immediate impact on our business,” Erzen said. “Do they have the chops to join our firm? So we look for that twinkle or that passion. And we definitely look for people who can come in and bring ideas.”

The Right Fit

Meanwhile, Johnson said when Serena asks a candidate in for a third interview it is to finalize their view of the person's technical competence.

“The final interview is to figure out if the candidate is the right fit,” he said. “And the final interview typically involves the hiring manager, someone from HR, and there can also be a team member and a higher level manager there.” Johnson says he looks for candidates who can effectively challenge the status quo. “Come with a little fire in the belly.”

“We're looking for candidates who want to make a contribution and not just plug along putting a widget in the exact spot every day,” Monarch said. “We also look for people who can work in ambiguity. Citrix requires a lot of collaborative work so those who can work in a team setting have better chances.”

Of the HR professionals interviewed, Colosi was the only one who said they do four rounds of interviews. And the fourth is typically to meet the company's CEO to get his approval. But by the fourth interview, “You've already got an offer.”

Other tips? Avoid distractions, Erzen said. This means to silence your cell phone. And do not pull out a PowerPoint presentation unless you're looking for a sales or marketing position. With most any other role, it's overkill, the HR pros said.

“It's very typical in the industry and probably for most companies to have a phone interview first, rather than taking the candidate's time to drive out to the site,” said Marilyn Monarch, group director for HR consulting and services at Citrix Systems.

Darryl K. Taft is a general assignment reporter for TheLadders





Featured Jobs

CEO/Head of School

Creative Learning Academy of Pensacola, Inc. “CLA” is seeking a chief executive to become Head of School beginning with the 2013-2014 school year. The successful candidate must have a history of significant business leadership and a proven track record of growth. Experience at an accredited independent school preferred, but not required.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Development

The WRUS Director of Development will have the opportunity to work within a collaborative, student centered professional environment, vigilant in our dedication to the success of bright high school students with learning differences, bound for college and post secondary learning.

Click to see complete job & apply

Fundraising and Development Director

Major Non-Profit organization in Carlsbad, NM is looking for a Fundraising and Development Director to join their team. This candidate must be someone with a proven track record developing and coordinating annual giving, donor stewardship and securing other forms of giving for a major Non-Profit organization.

Click to see complete job & apply

Major Gifts Officer

The International Fellowship of Christians and Jews ( The Fellowship ) is seeking a resourceful and dynamic individual as a Major Gifts Officer to promote our mission and build strong support among major donors. The MGO will engage, cultivate, and solicit current and prospective major donors in the western region of the US.

Click to see complete job & apply

Regional Director

The Regional Director supports multiple Executive Directors (EDs, 5-6) and community based Boards of Directors (5-6) in their region, serves as the Chief Executive of the region and is responsible for leadership and management development and support, board and resource development, marketing, and training needs of the assigned team members to ensure all performance goals are exceeded.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Major Gifts and Planned Giving

Responsibilities include developing and implementing a major and planned gifts development plan, and building a high-performing team, to achieve fundraising goals; managing a portfolio of donors; and serving as the primary liaison with financial advisors, attorneys, and other partners in the promotion and acquisition of gifts.

Click to see complete job & apply

Business Administrator

The position is responsible for the management of all financial and business aspects of the organization. Job responsibilities include: accounts payable and receivable, banking transactions and account, reconciliations, payroll, budget preparation and tracking, administration and record keeping of employee benefit programs, maintain all insurances, maintain donor and financial databases and preparation of financial reports.

Click to see complete job & apply

President and CEO

The United Way of Northern Arizona is seeking a proven, energetic leader as its next President and CEO. The new President and CEO will succeed the current President and CEO who is retiring after more than 14 years of outstanding, innovative leadership. UWNA has been recognized nationally for creating innovative collaborations and partnerships in its community impact areas of education, income and health.

Click to see complete job & apply


The Methodist Home for Children and Youth, a multi-faceted residential care home in Macon, Georgia, that addresses the needs of abused, neglected, and abandoned children, seeks a visionary administrator to guide and advance the operations and services as the President and CEO.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Foundation Relations

Seeking a Director of Foundation Relations to lead the effort to build and sustain relationships with national foundations and to leverage resources of the foundation community to help NSALA's reach its organizational goals and grow its new national initiative.

Click to see complete job & apply

Grants Manager

Use your experience with the grantmaking cycle to develop online applications, draft grant agreements, and track and review grantee reports. You will have primary responsibility for managing the grants management team's use of database and legal compliance technology.

Click to see complete job & apply

Chief Executive Officer

The Chief Executive Officer (CEO) oversees all operational aspects of the organization. This leader will be charged with oversight of fiscal and financial affairs, services provided, staff management, and the cultivation of community partnerships.

Click to see complete job & apply

Fundraising Manager

CRY America is CRY, Child Rights and You America Inc, a non profit organization registered in the USA in November 2002 that works towards restoring basic rights to underprivileged children, especially Indian. At CRY America we believe that each of us as individuals can make a difference.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Foundation Relations

Virginia Commonwealth University has an opening for an experienced, team-oriented Director of Foundation Relations. This position will report to the Senior Associate VP for Development and will serve as a member of the leadership team responsible for engaging national foundations. This individual will identify and cultivate new foundation partnerships on behalf of the university.

Click to see complete job & apply

Executive Director

With support and input from members of the board and staff, the Executive Director ensures the ethical integrity of the Foundation in daily operations as well as through strategic alliances and in various communiqué.

Click to see complete job & apply

Vice President of Development

Reporting directly to the President/CEO and serving on the executive team, directing a small team of fundraising professionals, this position will develop goals and strategies for fundraising programs incorporating major gifts, annual funds, government grants, corporate & foundation relations and planned giving.

Click to see complete job & apply

Senior Director, Foundation Relations

The Senior Director will focus on building high-level relationships between top foundations that will increase giving to support the American Heart Association mission. He or she will collaborate with volunteers and staff throughout the Western States Affiliate to achieve success. An emphasis will be on closing six-figure gifts to help us change and save lives.

Click to see complete job & apply

Director of Peer to Peer Fundraising

This position is responsible for the development and execution of the Agency's Peer to Peer fundraising strategy. The Peer to Peer strategy will focus on empowering individuals and groups to raise funds on behalf of the agency by allowing them to communicate and solicit prospective donors from their own networks and communities.

Click to see complete job & apply

More Jobs Like These »


Follow NPT

Stay Connected. Stay Informed.

Nonprofit news delivered around the clock, around the world.